Do women want midwives or obstetric nurses?

ISSN 0256-5004 (Print)

By Beverley Beech

AIMS Journal 2005, Vol 17, No 3

AIMS Chair Beverley Beech reflects on the success of the Birmingham Conference.

On the 1st October the Association of Radical Midwives (ARM) and AIMS jointly organised a conference, in Birmingham, to explore why midwives cannot support normal birth, and why women do not have any real choice within the NHS - and to come up with a strategy for real change.

While the rhetoric of choice suggests that women can get the care they want, the reality is that the majority of women have to accept what is on offer and the midwives have to do the best they can in an atmosphere that often does not support real midwifery practice or normality. Initially, it was intended that there would be 100 delegates, but 200 registered and many more were turned away.

One of the highlights of a conference, packed with first class speakers, was Steve Walker, the Chair of the NHS Litigation Authority, who came to explain the Clinical Negligence Scheme for Trusts (CNST). He handled well the stream of questions and examples of the difficulties midwives face as a result of CNST's requirements. Not only did the audience learn about the mysteries of CNST, but also he acknowledged that he himself had just undergone a significant learning curve listening to speakers and the audience, and invited representatives of AIMS, ARM and IMA to meet with him in the near future to discuss the problems.

Mavis Kirkham highlighted the problems midwives face working in environments that are not supportive of real midwifery practice. Jane Evans spoke about the issues an individual midwife faces daily, Barbara Hewson outlined the law, and Mary Cronk explained why midwives are reported to the Professional Conduct Committee. Lesley Price, a supervisor of midwives, demonstrated how CNST and good supervision can enhance the midwife's role, while Jean Robinson highlighted the concerns of consumers.

The star of the conference, however, was, Ruth Weston, the lay member who gave a presentation from a woman's perspective. She received a two minute standing ovation. Her presentation is printed in full on page 6.

The conference ended with a presentation from Brenda van der Kooy who showed how the Community Midwifery Model could give all midwives and women real choice in maternity care (see page 10). Every delegate left the conference after seeing a video of beautiful births with an action pack to encourage them to be proactive. For those who missed it, copies of the Action Pack can be downloaded from the AIMS web site: Midwifery for the 21st Century - ACTION NOW


Please feel free to download and share a pdf of this article. If you wish to use AIMS copyright material please see aims.org.uk/general/aims-copyright

If you found this article helpful please consider becoming an AIMS member or making a donation to support our work. We are a small charity that accepts no commercial sponsorship, in order to preserve our reputation for providing impartial, evidence-based information.

JOIN AIMS

MAKE A DONATION

Buy AIMS a Coffee with Ko-Fi

AIMS supports all maternity service users to navigate the system as it exists, and campaigns for a system which truly meets the needs of all.

Latest Content

Journal

« »

Imagining breech birth without bord…

AIMS Journal, 2026, Vol 38, No 3 By Rixa Freeze, PhD For a long time, breech birth lived in my mind as a question I could not quite put down. It was never just a clinical…

Read more

Supporting informed choice for wome…

AIMS Journal, 2026, Vol 38, No 3 By Amy Meadowcroft, RM, MClinRes Introduction This article uses the terms “women” and “mothers” in relation to biological sex and reprodu…

Read more

Mary Cronk MBE – Upholding the skil…

AIMS Journal, 2026, Vol 38, No 3 By Joy Horner For those who may not be familiar with the life and work of the late, great Mrs ("My friends call me Mary”) Cronk, she was…

Read more

Events

« »

ARM Winter National Meeting

Respect, Rights & Real Midwifery The ARM toolkit How do we not only survive but thrive in midwifery? Our winter meeting brings together midwives, students and supporters…

Read more

AIMS Workshop: The Foundation Stone…

Join us for one of our series of interactive online AIMS workshops " The Foundation Stones for Supporting the Physiological Process in Pregnancy and Birth ". Please follo…

Read more

Latest Campaigns

« »

Making Modern Service Frameworks: m…

By Catherine Williams, on behalf of the AIMS Campaigns Team Introduction: the Amos Review and the prospect of a Modern Service Framework for maternity The recommendations…

Read more

National maternity and neonatal ser…

By Jo Dagustun on behalf of the AIMS Campaigns Team In this briefing note, Jo offers an account of what has been happening following Wes Streeting’s 2024 commitment to ov…

Read more

Scottish Perinatal Framework: Alter…

AIMS was set to review the document Framework for maternity healthcare professionals to support individualised care for women who choose alternative/non-standard birth ch…

Read more