A Mother’s Instinct

ISSN 2516-5852 (Online)

AIMS Journal, 2023, Vol 35, No 2

Deborah and grown up daughter in the woods

By Deborah Maw

My first baby was born in Eire, although we were living in Dumfries and Galloway at the time, 20 miles from Dumfries - the nearest hospital.

I had my heart set on a homebirth; it was one of those ‘knowings’ that mothers get. I knew I must not be in hospital but, at about 7 months into my pregnancy, I was living alone in an isolated caravan, with no car or phone (way before the mobile-phone era), and the midwives who came to visit said, ‘No’.

They persuaded me to visit the hospital where I was taken to meet a consultant in what looked to me like a boardroom. He completely ridiculed my birth plan - because I wanted to be outside - and then barricaded the door when I tried to leave in floods of tears. I went straight to a phone box and called my friend in Eire who told me to come to her.

Everything then happened at once. I was given a council house but this was still 20 miles away from the hospital and I still had no phone. I moved in, bought a car and an old flat bed pram, persuaded a friend to accompany me and at 8 months pregnant I drove down to West Cork.

It was so beautiful. Late June, the weather was hot, the garden lush, and I settled into the last weeks of pregnancy with friends and babies all around.

The weeks passed. I was about two weeks overdue when I started with medium but regular contractions - for two days. They really kicked in on the third evening, but other than being exhausted nothing had changed by the following morning. I was hanging - literally from anything that would support me - in the garden as it was a beautiful day again. I went into the second stage mid morning. Our midwife friend came over. The hospital was over two hours away in Cork and we didn’t have a phone.

My waters broke - full of meconium - however it was obviously old and my baby’s heartbeat was good. The midwife was using a cardboard tube pinard (stethoscope) that worked perfectly well. But nothing was happening except that I was getting more and more ‘out of it’, being walked around the garden and using tree trunks to pull against as I pushed.

Three hours of second stage later, just after midday, my daughter was born, beneath a tree. After a bit of suctioning she was absolutely fine despite a very temporarily misshapen skull. 7lb. I already had her name since the caravan days - Geminy, with Bridget as a second name to honour my friend and the country of her birth.

We had to go to Skibbereen to register her birth. The registrant was completely discombobulated - and when we saw the register we realised why. My daughter was the first baby born in West Cork for over 20 years as everyone now went to hospital in Cork City. We returned to the UK a month later.

Geminy, now 34, is so grateful to have dual citizenship with a British and an EU passport. Because of the latter, she has just been accepted for a Canadian working visa. For Brits without an EU passport, it’s a random lottery.

I may have been running a risk, however, had I remained in ‘the system’ it is highly unlikely I would have been allowed to go two weeks overdue, or to be in first stage for three days, or second stage for three hours, especially after my baby had obviously been in distress at some point. As a primigravida mother (old at 31) I would have had medical intervention at some point - possibly resulting in a C-section. As it was, I hadn’t even torn. This meant I was able to go on and have two more home births - both with three hour second stages - and both with much bigger babies.

I highly recommend Ina May Gaskin’s book ‘Spiritual Midwifery’ for all mothers who want to trust their instinct and need to be fully informed.

For Geminy’s 30th birthday we returned to West Cork for a cycling tour holiday of the Beara Peninsula, visiting Bridget, Ballydehob (the village of Geminy’s birth), the house and the tree under which she was born.

Deborah's grown-up daughter sitting by the tree under which she was born


Author Bio: Deborah believes that everyone is free to make their own decisions, to follow their inner guidance. She began her education in science; however, after gaining a PGCE and PhD in Biochemistry, she changed track, travelling for 4 years before starting a family and re-training as a complementary therapist and artist. Deborah now works with people who want more freedom in their lives, freedom to follow their dreams.


Please feel free to download and share a pdf of this article. If you wish to use AIMS copyright material please see aims.org.uk/general/aims-copyright

If you found this article helpful please consider becoming an AIMS member or making a donation to support our work. We are a small charity that accepts no commercial sponsorship, in order to preserve our reputation for providing impartial, evidence-based information.

JOIN AIMS

MAKE A DONATION

Buy AIMS a Coffee with Ko-Fi

AIMS supports all maternity service users to navigate the system as it exists, and campaigns for a system which truly meets the needs of all.

Latest Content

Journal

« »

Imagining breech birth without bord…

AIMS Journal, 2026, Vol 38, No 3 By Rixa Freeze, PhD For a long time, breech birth lived in my mind as a question I could not quite put down. It was never just a clinical…

Read more

Supporting informed choice for wome…

AIMS Journal, 2026, Vol 38, No 3 By Amy Meadowcroft, RM, MClinRes Introduction This article uses the terms “women” and “mothers” in relation to biological sex and reprodu…

Read more

Mary Cronk MBE – Upholding the skil…

AIMS Journal, 2026, Vol 38, No 3 By Joy Horner For those who may not be familiar with the life and work of the late, great Mrs ("My friends call me Mary”) Cronk, she was…

Read more

Events

« »

ARM Winter National Meeting

Respect, Rights & Real Midwifery The ARM toolkit How do we not only survive but thrive in midwifery? Our winter meeting brings together midwives, students and supporters…

Read more

AIMS Workshop: The Foundation Stone…

Join us for one of our series of interactive online AIMS workshops " The Foundation Stones for Supporting the Physiological Process in Pregnancy and Birth ". Please follo…

Read more

Latest Campaigns

« »

Making Modern Service Frameworks: m…

By Catherine Williams, on behalf of the AIMS Campaigns Team Introduction: the Amos Review and the prospect of a Modern Service Framework for maternity The recommendations…

Read more

National maternity and neonatal ser…

By Jo Dagustun on behalf of the AIMS Campaigns Team In this briefing note, Jo offers an account of what has been happening following Wes Streeting’s 2024 commitment to ov…

Read more

Scottish Perinatal Framework: Alter…

AIMS was set to review the document Framework for maternity healthcare professionals to support individualised care for women who choose alternative/non-standard birth ch…

Read more